Stocks Split in Wednesday Trading: Health Care Dragged the Dow While the Nasdaq Held Steady, and the Fed Minutes Pointed Toward a December Hike

Key takeaways
- In a late Wednesday morning reading around 10:46 to 11:05 a.m. Eastern the market was split: the Dow fell about 1.2 percent, down roughly 607 points, while the Nasdaq Composite held near flat and the S&P 500 was down about 0.5 percent.
- Health care was the Dow's heaviest drag, led by UnitedHealth down about 6 percent after the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services proposed a new anti-fraud rule for insurers.
- UnitedHealth's slide subtracted roughly 122 to 132 points from the Dow, among the heaviest drags along with Chevron and Caterpillar, but well short of the full decline, so other members falling accounted for the rest.
- Nvidia beat with revenue of about $115.8 billion and data center sales up about 110 percent and guided the current quarter to roughly $130 billion, yet the stock gave back a premarket pop and traded down about 2 percent.
- The 2 p.m. Eastern release of the October 27 to 28 Fed minutes showed almost all officials viewing further rate increases as appropriate, with a couple noting a move larger than a quarter point could be considered in December if inflation data were unfavorable, in line with prediction markets putting December hike odds near 96 percent.
- Lowe's topped the headline at about $3.10 a share, but roughly $0.34 came from tariff refunds, leaving about $2.76 without that benefit, below the roughly $2.88 estimate, and it also trimmed operating-margin guidance.
The market split in two on Wednesday morning. The weakest corner was health care, where a slide in big insurers dragged on the price-weighted Dow, while the tech-heavy Nasdaq held near flat and the S&P 500 slipped about half a percent. The result was a tape that looked green or red depending on which index you watched.
As of late morning, in a 10:46 a.m. Eastern reading, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was down about 607 points, roughly 1.2 percent, while the S&P 500 was down about 0.5 percent and the Nasdaq Composite held near flat, according to market trackers and live coverage. The levels kept moving, and by early afternoon the Dow's decline had narrowed, but the shape held: the Dow carried the weakest hand while the broader list drifted modestly lower.
The divergence is easier to explain once you look under the hood. The Dow is price weighted, so a single higher-priced stock swings it more than a cheaper one does. A major drag was UnitedHealth, one of the Dow's most heavily weighted members by share price, which fell about 6 percent (down 6.07 percent in an 11:05 a.m. reading) after the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services proposed a new anti-fraud rule for the industry. Other insurers such as Humana, Cigna, and CVS Health slid too, but those names are not in the Dow, so their moves showed up in the broader indexes instead. Chips were mixed rather than roaring, and Nvidia itself turned lower, off about 2 percent. The Nasdaq instead leaned on a few large members: Broadcom rose about 3.6 percent, Amazon about 2.2 percent, and Alphabet was slightly higher.
Nvidia delivered, and the stock could not hold its early pop
The quarter itself was not the problem. According to the company's earnings release, Nvidia reported fiscal third-quarter revenue of about $115.8 billion, up roughly 103 percent from a year earlier. Data center revenue came in near $107.6 billion, up about 110 percent year over year. Non-GAAP earnings landed at about $2.68 per share versus $1.27 a year ago. The company guided the current quarter to about $130 billion, give or take 3 percent. On the buyback, Nvidia said it had roughly $227.3 billion remaining under a share repurchase authorization with no expiration, available to spend over time rather than a target it must hit.
The stock's response told the more interesting story. Nvidia jumped about 3 percent before the opening bell, then gave it back and traded down about 2 percent in late-morning action, extending a multi-day losing streak. We wrote this morning in the main story on the quarter about why a clean beat can still leave a stock cold: when a company is expected to be great, merely being great is already in the price. Nvidia also walked into this report down over the prior month and carrying the overhang of its first earnings release since the abrupt departure of its founder, so some buyers stayed on the sidelines.
Health care weighed on the Dow
If there was a single reason the Dow lagged the Nasdaq, it was health care rather than technology. UnitedHealth, which carries about a 4 percent weight in the price-weighted Dow, slid roughly 6 percent on the proposed anti-fraud rule, and the broader group of managed-care names fell alongside it. A 4 percent weight times a 6 percent drop subtracts only about 0.24 percent from the Dow, roughly 122 points off Tuesday's close near 50,759; Yahoo Finance's higher 4.32 percent weight gets closer to 132. That made it one of the heaviest drags on the board, alongside Chevron and Caterpillar, but well short of the full decline, so the rest came from other Dow members falling and the index's steeper percentage move.
Retail beat the numbers, and the reaction split down the middle
Two big-box retailers reported before the bell and muddied the picture. Lowe's topped forecasts on the headline, with adjusted earnings of about $3.10 a share against an estimate near $2.88, and it raised its annual sales outlook. The reaction was cooler than that beat suggests. The company trimmed its operating-margin guidance, and about $0.34 of that $3.10 came from tariff refunds. Strip the refund out and adjusted earnings were closer to $2.76 a share, below the roughly $2.88 that analysts expected. Gross margin also narrowed from a year earlier. The stock fell about 4 percent in premarket trading and was still modestly lower once the regular session opened.
Target took the opposite path. The stock dipped in premarket trading, then turned higher once regular trading began, rising about 4 percent in late-morning action on its strongest sales growth in several years. Part of its beat, like Lowe's, leaned on tariff refunds, so the quality of the result drew some of the same scrutiny. By late morning, Target was a gainer, not a decliner.
The Fed minutes just landed, and one test is still ahead
The morning's action was only half the day. One scheduled event has now crossed the tape, and one more still sits ahead of the close.
First, the Federal Reserve released the minutes from its October 27 to 28 meeting at 2 p.m. Eastern. At that meeting the Fed held its policy rate at 3.75 to 4.00 percent on a 10 to 2 vote, with the two dissenters preferring a quarter-point increase. According to the minutes published on the Federal Reserve's site, almost all participants judged that further action to raise rates would likely be appropriate to push inflation back toward 2 percent, and a couple of participants noted that an increase of more than a quarter point could warrant consideration in December if incoming inflation data were unfavorable. That sits on top of a stronger-than-expected October jobs report and a hot October inflation reading. Prediction markets already leaned heavily toward an increase in December. As of November 16, the market platform Kalshi put the odds of any rate increase at the December 8 to 9 meeting near 96 percent, with about 87.5 percent on a quarter-point move and roughly 8.5 percent on a larger half-point step, according to a roundup of those markets. Those are prediction-market readings, not a guaranteed outcome. We laid out what a December hike instead of a cut would mean for borrowers and savers in our explainer on Wall Street's rate-hike base case.
Second, Anthropic, the maker of the Claude AI assistant, is still expected to price its initial public offering Wednesday evening, with trading set to begin Thursday on the Nasdaq under the ticker ANT. The company is marketing 825 million shares in a range of $70 to $78, which could raise as much as roughly $64.4 billion, one of the largest offerings on record. We walked through what a deal this size means for ordinary investors in our guide to the Anthropic IPO. A live pricing has not happened yet as of this writing.
What a split tape means if you own index funds
For someone whose money sits in an S&P 500 or total-market fund, the useful takeaway is not any single stock. It is the narrowness. When one sector drags the Dow lower while the broader list slips only modestly, the headline level can hide a lot of churn underneath. An S&P 500 down about half a percent on a day like this is not a quiet day; it is a tug-of-war in which the losers barely edged the winners.
None of that calls for action. The volatility gauge known as the VIX, which climbed to 25.46 on Tuesday, November 17, up about 2.55 points from the prior close near 22.91, reflects that unsettled mood. Over long stretches, the steadier path tends to come from owning the whole market and leaving the day-to-day sorting to the market itself.
By late morning the market story was unresolved, which fits the week. Nvidia cleared its bar but could not hold an early gain, health care weighed on the Dow, and Lowe's beat the headline without reward while Target rallied intraday. Since then the Fed minutes have landed on the hawkish side, confirming a committee leaning toward another rate increase, while the Anthropic pricing is still due after the bell. We will keep updating as the afternoon unfolds.
Most investors cannot pass a basic money test. Can you?
The market charges tuition for every gap in your knowledge. The Financial IQ Test measures what you actually know across investing, banking, credit, and retirement, then shows you exactly which gaps to close before they get expensive.
Test your Financial IQQuestions people ask
Why did the Dow fall while the Nasdaq held up on the same morning?
The two indexes hold different mixes of stocks and weight them differently. The morning's heaviest loss was in health care, where UnitedHealth fell about 6 percent after regulators proposed a new anti-fraud rule for insurers. UnitedHealth is one of the highest-priced stocks in the price-weighted Dow, so its slide pulled hard on that index, though by the math it accounted for only about 122 to 132 points rather than the whole decline. Other insurers that fell, such as Humana, Cigna, and CVS Health, are not in the Dow, so their moves landed in the broader indexes instead. The Nasdaq, meanwhile, got a lift from gains in Broadcom, Amazon and Alphabet. That mix is why the same session looked red on the Dow but near flat on the Nasdaq, with the S&P 500 down only about half a percent in between.
How much did UnitedHealth actually subtract from the Dow?
Less than the headlines might suggest. UnitedHealth carries about a 4 percent weight in the price-weighted Dow, and a 4 percent weight times a roughly 6 percent drop removes about 0.24 percent of the index. Against Tuesday's close near 50,759, that is roughly 122 points, and Yahoo Finance's slightly higher 4.32 percent weight gets you closer to 132. It was among the heaviest drags on the board, with Chevron and Caterpillar also weighing on the index, but it did not pull the Dow down by several hundred points on its own; the rest came from other members falling too.
What did the Fed minutes released at 2 p.m. show?
The minutes from the October 27 to 28 meeting came out at 2 p.m. Eastern on Wednesday. At that meeting the Fed held its rate at 3.75 to 4.00 percent on a 10 to 2 vote, with the two dissenters wanting a quarter-point increase. The record showed almost all participants judging that further rate increases would likely be appropriate to bring inflation back toward 2 percent, and a couple of participants noted that an increase of more than a quarter point could warrant consideration in December if inflation data came in unfavorable. The minutes did not lock in the size of any December move, but they confirmed the committee is leaning toward tightening, which matched prediction-market odds that already pointed heavily toward a December increase.
Nvidia beat expectations, so why did the stock fall?
When a company is widely expected to post a huge quarter, a huge quarter is already reflected in the share price, so a clean beat confirms the story rather than adding to it. Nvidia popped about 3 percent before the bell, then gave it back and traded down roughly 2 percent in late morning, extending a losing streak. It also entered the report down over the prior month and faced an overhang from its first earnings release since its founder's departure, which kept some buyers cautious.
Lowe's beat estimates, so why did it slip?
The headline adjusted figure of about $3.10 a share topped the roughly $2.88 estimate, but the details were softer. The company trimmed its operating-margin guidance, and about $0.34 of that $3.10 came from tariff refunds. Without the refund, adjusted earnings were closer to $2.76, below the estimate, and gross margin narrowed from a year earlier. The stock fell about 4 percent premarket and stayed modestly lower in the regular session as investors focused on those offsets.
Should I do anything with my index funds on a day like this?
A split tape is normal and does not call for action on its own. It mostly shows that one sector is dragging while the rest of the list slips only modestly. This article is general information, not personalized advice. For most long-term savers, the steadier approach is owning a broad fund and letting the market sort out the day-to-day rotation rather than reacting to a single morning's moves.
Keep reading

How to Choose a Brokerage Account in 2026: A Practical Guide

Dividend Investing for Beginners: Income You Can Actually See

Dollar-Cost Averaging: The Math, the Myths, and When It Wins
The Flourish Letter
One smart money idea each week, charts included. Join free and get the printable 2026 Money Calendar in your welcome email.